Five epic fails that cost Marilyn Mosby the Freddie Gray case

Five epic fails that cost Marilyn Mosby the Freddie Gray case

More than a year after the death of Freddie Gray and the ensuing riots, all six charged Baltimore police officers walked free and the attorney who prosecuted them faces a mountain of lawsuits, possible disbarment, and calls for her resignation.

While the lawsuits face a tough battle and the disbarment is unlikely, Baltimore State’s Attorney Marilyn Mosby did make a series of mistakes in the trial that cost her. Here are five of Mosby’s biggest missteps.

1. Overzealous Charges

When Mosby announced charges against the officers, the legal community largely felt she overstepped. While the death certainly warranted prosecution, she hit all six officers involved with a slew of charges including involuntary manslaughter, assault, and depraved-heart murder. These charges came just one day after the police department gave her its investigation. The Baltimore police union quickly accused her of rushing to judgment.

Mosby charged the van driver, Officer Caesar Goodson, with depraved-heart murder, a somewhat unusual and difficul- to-prove count. To prove depraved-heart murder, a prosecutor must show evidence that the killer acted even though he was conscious that his actions posed an unusually high risk of killing or seriously hurting another person. Proving state of mind can be tricky.

2. Biased Speech

After the Baltimore riots, Mosby gave a rousing press conference that sparked accusations of bias and led to legal challenges from the officers. In the speech, Mosby raised eyebrows with her fiery rhetoric.

“To the people of Baltimore and the demonstrators across America, I heard your call for ‘No justice, no peace,’” she said. “Your peace is seriously needed as I seek to deliver justice to this young man.”

Mosby now faces legal trouble from the officers, who allege that they were inappropriately attacked in the speech as scapegoats to quell the Baltimore riots. They say Mosby knew the charges brought against them were bogus and that she only filed them to calm the city. They point to her rhetoric in the speech as evidence.

3. Missed Grand Jury Opportunity

Mosby did not fully use the investigatory powers of the grand jury, and it may have cost her crucial evidence. Grand juries have two main functions: an investigatory capacity to gather evidence or to hear evidence from a prosecutor, and then decide whether to indict. Mosby opted for the latter while she conducted her own hurried, independent investigation. The grand jury may have turned up new evidence that could have helped the prosecution.

Rene Sandler, a Maryland attorney and former prosecutor, told The Daily Caller News Foundation earlier this month the mistake likely cost Mosby a conviction:

I would say her rush to judgment in determining that ‘her’ investigation supported the probable cause necessary to charge these officers rather than fully utilizing the grand jury process likely resulted in the loss of a conviction. Mosby has publicly stated that she made her decision to file criminal charges against the officers based on an ‘independent’ investigation done by her office. Had she utilized the grand jury fully to investigate, the grand jury may have declined the indictment rather than to indict after having been presented with a self-serving investigation done by her own office.

4. Hidden Evidence 

Mosby’s office drew the ire of Judge Barry Williams when it failed to turn over evidence to the defense in Goodson’s trial.

“I’m telling you that this [evidence] needs to be considered,” Williams told Chief Deputy State’s Attorney Michael Schatzow. “If you don’t understand that, then I don’t know what else you don’t understand.”

“Isn’t that your duty, counsel? To turn things over?” Williams said before opening statements. “What else is out there that you didn’t turn over?”

5. Failure to Convict Van Driver

The last and most crucial mistake in the case came when the prosecution failed to convict Goodson. The entire case hung on the idea that Goodson gave Gray a “rough ride” where he intentionally drove recklessly to sling Gray around in the back. Once Mosby couldn’t prove that the van driver’s actions caused the death, she had little chance of proving that the indirectly related officers should be held accountable as well.

Some legal experts pointed out that despite Mosby’s mistakes, this was a difficult case to win. Prosecuting police officers brings its own set of challenges and the questions surrounding how Gray actually died made this case difficult. Regardless, Mosby’s mistakes plagued the prosecution’s case and now Baltimore is left feeling like justice was not done because of it.

This report, by Casey Harper, was cross-posted by arrangement with the Daily Caller News Foundation.

LU Staff

LU Staff

Promoting and defending liberty, as defined by the nation’s founders, requires both facts and philosophical thought, transcending all elements of our culture, from partisan politics to social issues, the workings of government, and entertainment and off-duty interests. Liberty Unyielding is committed to bringing together voices that will fuel the flame of liberty, with a dialogue that is lively and informative.


Commenting Policy

We have no tolerance for comments containing violence, racism, vulgarity, profanity, all caps, or discourteous behavior. Thank you for partnering with us to maintain a courteous and useful public environment where we can engage in reasonable discourse.

You may use HTML in your comments. Feel free to review the full list of allowed HTML here.