Lesbians who torched own house, alleging it was ‘hate crime,’ lose lawsuit

Lesbians who torched own house, alleging it was ‘hate crime,’ lose lawsuit
Credit: Knoxville News

Carol Ann Stutte and Laura Jean Stutte went to great lengths to prove themselves the victims of anti-gay discrimination. The lesbian couple burned down their own home in Monroe County, Tenn., and claimed a neighbor had started the fire as an act of hate. But on Monday the Stuttes’ lost the lawsuit they filed against their insurance company, American National Property and Casualty Company, which had denied their claim on the grounds that the incident was a hoax.

“In the verdict, the jury specifically concluded the insurer had proved by what’s known as a preponderance of the evidence standard that the Stuttes torched their house,” the Knoxville News Sentinel notes. The plaintiffs then attempted to conceal the self-destructive act by spray-painting the word “queers” on a detached garage and accused a neighbor, Janice Millsaps, of setting the blaze.

The Stuttes’ house was destroyed … in September 2010. The couple at the time blamed … Millsaps in media interviews and a lawsuit filed against Millsaps in Monroe County Chancery Court.

In that lawsuit, the Stuttes alleged Millsaps “repeatedly threatened the lives of the Stuttes” and “specifically and repeatedly threatened to burn the Stuttes’ house.”

The Stuttes claimed in the lawsuit that Millsaps, a month before the fire, said to them: “Do you know what is better than one dead queer? Two dead queers.”

Millsaps denied any role in the fire and has not been charged despite extensive probes by the FBI, the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation and local arson investigators, according to Millsaps’ attorney, Lewis Kinnard.

The insurer concluded after its own probe, which included a lie detector test administered to Millsaps, that the Stuttes were not fire victims but fire bugs.

In the end, the Stuttes should consider themselves lucky. Authorities have not pressed charges against them in the house arson.

Related Articles

Howard Portnoy

Howard Portnoy

Howard Portnoy has written for The Blaze, HotAir, NewsBusters, Weasel Zippers, Conservative Firing Line, RedCounty, and New York’s Daily News. He has one published novel, Hot Rain, (G. P. Putnam’s Sons), and has been a guest on Radio Vice Online with Jim Vicevich, The Alana Burke Show, Smart Life with Dr. Gina, and The George Espenlaub Show.


Commenting Policy

We have no tolerance for comments containing violence, racism, vulgarity, profanity, all caps, or discourteous behavior. Thank you for partnering with us to maintain a courteous and useful public environment where we can engage in reasonable discourse.

You may use HTML in your comments. Feel free to review the full list of allowed HTML here.