Texas fails school-choice test

Texas fails school-choice test
Credit: MacIver Institute

Free marketer Milton Friedman would surely be perplexed by the state of education in Texas.

The late Nobel Prize-winning economist — who would have turned 103 this year — long advocated for school reform through the Friedman Foundation for Educational Choice.

As one of the most conservative and entrepreneurial states in the nation, Texas has been a leading laboratory for Friedman’s market-driven formulas. But while building the economic guru’s low-tax, low-regulation model, the Lone Star State sticks to business as usual with K-12 government schools.

“Education is socialized,” says Larry Taylor, chairman of the Senate Education Committee. “There’s no free market.”

Indeed, Texas’s “Robin Hood” funding system just spreads the money around, with dubious results. The law requires districts with high property values or energy revenue to turn over millions of dollars in property taxes to poorer districts.

Attempting to loosen the statist stranglehold, the Senate passed a modest tax-credit scholarship bill to empower parents. But the House – led by Speaker Joe Strauss and backed by minority Democrats — blocked the legislation, leaving Texas a laggard in the national push for school choice.

Taylor and other advocates vow to keep trying. They frame parental choice as the civil-rights cause of the 21st century.

“It crosses all racial and economic groups,” says Robin Lennon, a co-founder of the Kingwood Tea Party.

Proponents say a choice law can begin to broaden opportunities for Texans.

“You have kids stuck with crummy school districts. You can have schools in the ‘failing’ category for five years,” Taylor notes. “Choice is the ultimate solution.”

Metrics undermine the conventional wisdom that more public spending translates into better education. Per-pupil allocations have risen steadily in Texas — growing five times faster than enrollment — while SAT scores have remained flat. Outlays for non-teaching positions have climbed 172%.

Texas’ $70 billion public-school complex consumes more than 40% of the state’s general fund and 55% of local property taxes.

Yet a Watchdog.org analysis of Texas’ top-rated five-star schools and their budgets revealed no correlation between academic performance and spending.

Select and compare school districts here.

“It’s not about bureaucrats. It should be about teaching students,” said Taylor, R-Friendswood.

Taking on the state teacher unions, Taylor says school choice would bust up the government-sponsored monopoly in public education and reward quality instructors.

“The best teachers will never get the salaries they deserve until there is free-market competition. It’s no wonder that there’s high turnover. The teachers union defends the worst of the worst,” Taylor said.

Peggy Venable, senior states policy adviser for the Americans for Prosperity Foundation, said Friedman would be eager for Texas to move forward on school choice.

“Choice is a way of life for Americans. Inexplicably, many who might reject a monopoly elsewhere accept it in education,” Venable said.

Read more by Kenric Ward at Watchdog.com.

Kenric Ward

Kenric Ward

Kenric Ward is a national correspondent and writes for the Texas Bureau of Watchdog.org. Formerly a reporter and editor at two Pulitzer Prize-winning newspapers, Kenric has won dozens of state and national news awards for investigative articles. His most recent book is “Saints in Babylon: Mormons and Las Vegas.”


Commenting Policy

We have no tolerance for comments containing violence, racism, vulgarity, profanity, all caps, or discourteous behavior. Thank you for partnering with us to maintain a courteous and useful public environment where we can engage in reasonable discourse.

You may use HTML in your comments. Feel free to review the full list of allowed HTML here.