God is dead, or at least not welcome in school assemblies. That is the message emanating from a North Carolina elementary school, which expurgated a reference to God in a first grader’s poem.
The Daily Caller avoids mentioning the child’s name but notes that she attends West Marion Elementary School. The poem was to be read in its entirety at a Nov. 8 Veterans Day ceremony to honor her grandfather, a Vietnam veteran.
That was until someone in the administration noticed that the poem contained the line, “He prayed to God for peace, he prayed to God for strength,” which needed to go.
A statement from the Alliance Defending Freedom, a group that advocates for religious rights and freedoms, criticizes the school’s decision. It reads in part:
America’s public schools should encourage, not restrict, the constitutionally protected freedom of students to express their faith. Students should not be censored when speaking about their faith or honoring those who valiantly served to protect our freedoms.… The censorship of this young student’s poem about her grandfathers is repugnant to the First Amendment rights of all students and sends an impermissible message of hostility towards religion.
But not everyone sees it that way. The DC offer the dissenting view written by First Amendment Center president and CEO Ken Paulson, who maintains that child has every right to mention God but not to inflict her beliefs on others. “When they asked her to read [the poem] at an assembly,” Paulson adds, the “dynamic changed.”
In Paulson’s view, the school was legally obligated to delete the reference to God, because public schools cannot sanction religious messages in captive environments like classrooms or assemblies.
A search of the First Amendment Center’s website turned up no reaction to either of two 2011 stories which would seem right up their alley. One involved a Georgia middle school teacher who included tenets of Sharia law in a lesson on the pros and cons of school uniforms. The other centered on a 12-year-old New Hampshire child whose American flag was confiscated by school administrators. A Google search using the same parameters for each story also came up empty.
It is possible, one supposes, that Paulson’s organization simply missed these stories. It is also possible that the watchdog group picks and chooses which incidents to take sides in.
Related Articles
- British schools drop Holocaust from history lessons so as not to offend Muslims
- School up in arms over student’s mural depicting ‘nuclear family’
- NH school confiscates autistic 12-year-old boy’s American flag
- NYC public school to require students grades 2 through 5 to learn Arabic
- Teacher tells 6th grade class that ‘Republicans are stupid’
- NYC Dept of Ed publishes its list of 50 ‘forbidden words’
- Defense Department authorizes Muslim cadets’ wearing of hijabs, turbans
- Georgia middle schoolers learn ‘positives’ of Sharia law
- American-born Muslim convert tells fellow Muslims to kill Americans
- White House anti-bullying summit in NY addresses specter of ‘Islamophobia’
- Islamic “jury” offers $2.2 million for head of Koran-burning FL pastor
- True Islamophobia and standing up to death threats from Islamic extremists
- The myth of rampant Islamophobia
- Undercover footage shows beatings, worse at Britain’s Muslim schools
- Poll: Muslim world rejects Obama’s outreach
- New Ground Zero imam: “True” Muslims follow Sharia law
Follow me on Twitter or join me at Facebook. You can also reach me at howard.portnoy@gmail.com.
The slippery slope continues
Howard, I read about this over a week ago. Please add a tip line on your things to do list.
Thanks.
JP, thank you for pointing this out! I’m a little surprised that The Daily Caller was so late on it as well.
As to the tip line, that’s an excellent idea. Were currently in the midst of our post-launch redesign so your timing is perfect.
well Howard…first we blame Bush, then we blame god if that doesn’t work. we continue to destroy the entire concept of “diversity” (that concept that built this country and gives us all those choices in restaurants!).
We employed a german woman for years that was a “Hitler youth” (or as my cousin Vinnie would say “Hitler yoot”). I guess the summer camp experience was ok.
Maybe it’s just me that sees where we are heading.
Change G-d to Allah and Vietnam to Egypt, resubmit next year and see what happens. Like there’s any doubt. We don’t have a separation of Church and State, we have a separation of Christianity and State.
I love the tip line idea. The schools are way out of control.