Criminal largely avoids jail despite 63 arrests, many convictions, and despite falsely getting innocent man arrested and jailed for two years

Criminal largely avoids jail despite 63 arrests, many convictions, and despite falsely getting innocent man arrested and jailed for two years
Chelsea Steiniger

A woman in central Virginia has been arrested 63 times, convicted repeatedly, yet has never done any serious jail time. She is a menace to her fellow citizens: She falsely accused an innocent man who gave her a ride of rape, for which she was never prosecuted; he spent two years in jail before being released. Bacon’s Rebellion writes:

Chelsea Eileen Steiniger, a 31-year-old Buckingham County woman … may have accomplished the feat of having been arrested more often — 63 times — than anyone else in Central Virginia.

One reason she has been arrested so frequently, it appears, is the leniency of judges who are reluctant to sentence her to jail time.

“It’s become a philosophy that you don’t want to put someone in prison for a low-level, low-dollar-amount crime,” Charlottesville lawyer Scott Goodman told the newspaper. “It’s basically treated as a sickness as much as it is a crime these days. If you show any kind of an effort that you’re trying to overcome your addiction, that goes a long way with the courts.”

General District Court Judge Matthew Quatrara recently found her guilty of numerous offenses in Albemarle County, including contempt and check larceny, but he imposed suspended sentences. He did sentence her for 30 says on a charge of driving under the influence, however.

In 2012 she claimed that she had been abducted and raped by a local man who gave her a ride. He served more than two years in jail before his defense produced evidence portraying Steiniger as a fabulist who concocted a tale to anger a boyfriend. She was never charged with perjury. In another case, she stole a nurse’s scooter at the University of Virginia Medical Center. She served no time for that either, although she was ordered to pay restitution.

Steiniger currently faces another 20 charges in Buckingham County relating to identity theft, trading in stolen goods and entering a house to commit assault and battery. Many of her current and past charges also involve drugs.

“Ms. Steiniger,” asked Quatrara at her recent hearing, “what is the longest period you’ve been drug-free?”

“Six months,” she answered.

“I’m happy to see you alive,” said the judge. “When I didn’t see you for a long time, I was concerned that your issues had gotten the best of you and that I was going to read your obituary in the newspaper.”…

We often hear that jail is a terrible, wasteful place to house drug addicts, alcoholics, and the mentally ill. Really? Sixty-three crimes implies 63 victims along the way — not including an innocent man who spent two years in jail.

How many people does Steiniger have to rob or defraud before society says “enough”?

Incarceration deters crimes, as studies have found. Jail also incapacitates offenders, preventing them from committing more crimes while they are behind bars. Violent crime plunged dramatically in El Salvador, preventing countless killings, when it increased incarceration rates. Studies of countries with very low incarceration rates have found that letting criminals out early increases the crime rate, and that higher levels of incarceration are a good investment

Some left-wingers falsely claim America is a place of “mass incarceration” and “overpolicing.” But in reality, far from being overpoliced, the U.S. is actually less policed than most of the world, with fewer cops than Europe. As criminology professor Justin Nix points out, “Given its level of serious crime, America has ordinary levels of incarceration but extraordinary levels of under-policing.”


For your convenience, you may leave commments below using Disqus. If Disqus is not appearing for you, please disable AdBlock to leave a comment.