Did the DOJ and FBI withhold info from Congress about ‘white supremacists’ and terror attacks?

Did the DOJ and FBI withhold info from Congress about ‘white supremacists’ and terror attacks?
Cory Booker (Image: YouTube screen grab via MSNBC)

A new theme is zooming around the Web: that Congress asked the U.S. Department of Justice for statistical information on the source of domestic terror attacks, and the DOJ was “unwilling or unable” to give Congress a “government document” that contains the information.

Yahoo News did the honors of issuing the report on this.  We’ll see if other mainstream media pick it up.  It’s getting lots of play on social media.

Trending: Elijah Cummings died this morning: Too soon to make it political?

Jamil Smith’s tweet indicates that the big takeaway from the government document is that “White supremacists were responsible for every single incident of domestic terrorism in 2018.”

According to the Yahoo News article, Senator Cory Booker (D-NJ) was ready with a prompt reaction to the emergence of this document.

“I’m troubled by the lack of transparency, given that we haven’t received this critical information after several requests to the FBI and DOJ. They cannot and should not remain silent in the face of such a dangerous threat,” Sen. Cory Booker, D-N.J., wrote in an email, after being told about the data.

Yahoo News has yet to explain how the document has “become public,” but does record for us the reaction of an aide to Senator Dick Durbin (D-IL) as well.

An aide to Sen. Dick Durbin, D-Ill., who is also on the Judiciary Committee, said it was “disappointing” to discover the Justice Department has information it has been “unable or unwilling” to provide to senators.

“This is disappointing but unfortunately not surprising. In April, the Justice Department and the FBI briefed Senate Judiciary Committee staff on domestic terrorism, nearly six months after Sen. Durbin’s office first requested the briefing,” the aide said. “At the briefing, the DOJ and the FBI were unable or unwilling to provide precise data on white supremacist terrorism, and neither agency has responded to our repeated follow-up questions since the briefing.”

What is the document?  It is titled “Domestic Terrorism in 2018,” it’s “dated April 15, 2019,” and it “was prepared by New Jersey’s Office of Homeland Security Preparedness, one of the main arteries of information sharing, and sent throughout the DHS fusion center network as well as federal agencies, including the FBI.”

In other words, it’s a document prepared by an agency in the state of New Jersey.

You can download the PDF of the document here.

The first thing you’ll notice about the document is the disclaimer on the download page, which reads:

All information was derived from publicly available sources.

Screen cap by author. Click screen caps to enlarge for legibility

The second thing you’ll notice is that the document consists entirely of the graphic presentation embedded using Scribd at the Yahoo News site.

It’s one page, and the one page is the graphic.  It lists each of the domestic terror crimes it cites, with identifying info on the perpetrator and arrest date.  It maps them all by location.  What it doesn’t do is provide any source information on the attacks, such as links to either media reporting or law enforcement information, or even just citations.

NJOHSP graphic of domestic terror incidents in 2018. For original graphic see NJOHSP PDF document linked in text, or view it as a Scribd document at the Yahoo News link.

The third thing you’ll notice is that the graphic doesn’t say “white supremacists” were responsible for every single incident of domestic terrorism in 2018.  According to the tally of little ‘splody red icons, there were 31 actual attacks, of which 21 were committed by white supremacists.  Ten were committed by perps in other categories.

It would be childish in the extreme to complain that the criticisms here of the Yahoo News scoop are about denying the reality of “white supremacist” violence.  I trust no one will express such a silly reaction.

The point is that this is not a document the DOJ has any business forwarding to Congress, and we may be grateful to the level heads at DOJ for refraining from doing so.

This is not to impugn the New Jersey OHSP’s work, which I am sure was done in good faith and represents their best assessment.  But it’s not the DOJ’s or FBI’s work. As such, it would not be responsive to a congressional request as the DOJ has every reason to interpret it.  When the Senate asks the DOJ for data, the Senate either (a) does not mean “Please provide us with a graphic presentation of publicly-available information from a state agency in New Jersey,” or (b) will say so if that’s what the Senate does mean.

We can also note in passing that there may be a reason Senator Booker, D-NJ, was able to provide a reaction to the media with such alacrity.  The suspicion does intrude that he was already aware of the NJOHSP graphic.  Perhaps he had special alertment to it.

But he didn’t really need it.  That’s the other thing you’ll note about the document.  It isn’t “becoming public” in August 2019.  It’s been public since it was placed online, apparently – according to the page source information – on 15 April 2019.

J.E. Dyer

J.E. Dyer

J.E. Dyer is a retired Naval Intelligence officer who lives in Southern California, blogging as The Optimistic Conservative for domestic tranquility and world peace. Her articles have appeared at Hot Air, Commentary’s Contentions, Patheos, The Daily Caller, The Jewish Press, and The Weekly Standard.