VA Governor-elect Terry McAuliffe’s light-rail pipe dream

VA Governor-elect Terry McAuliffe’s light-rail pipe dream

The TideBarack Obama is not the only Democrat who likes to play with trains. Terry McAuliffe likes public-transit projects, too, and so does the Virginia governor-elect’s transportation secretary, Aubrey Layne, who declared last week, “We must do what we can to get cars off the road by investing in passenger rail and light rail.

Extending “The Tide,” Norfolk’s lightly traveled light-rail line to Virginia Beach is a priority for Layne, a real-estate developer who represents Hampton Roads on the Commonwealth Transportation Board.

Skeptics warn that such commuter lines won’t go far, even with outgoing Gov. Bob McDonnell’s multibillion-dollar transportation package in hand.

“The massive investments required for rail transit usually serve a small share of the people in an urban area,” says Randal O’Toole, a transportation analyst for the free-market Cato Institute.

“Spending huge amounts of money on a narrow segment often leads to significant declines in the region’s transportation network,” he says.

Examining light-rail systems across the country, O’Toole finds they invariably:

  • Underperform ridership estimates and overspend their budgets.
  • Cost more than bus lines.
  • Fail to stimulate the economy.
  • Place added stress on existing transportation networks.

Calling light rail a form of “transit apartheid,” O’Toole says, “The financial stresses created by the high cost of rail often lead transit agencies to raise fares and cut bus service, thus harming low-income families.”

Right on time, the Hampton Roads transit commission is recommending a 33% fare increase on Norfolk’s bus routes and The Tide.

After three years in operation, use of the 7.4-mile rail system has flat-lined at a modest weekly average of barely 5,000 riders.

According to data from the American Public Transportation Association, The Tide carries the lowest number of riders per mile of any light-rail system in the nation.

O’Toole finds “many transit agencies that build new rail lines quickly demonstrate a level of incompetence they did not display when running only buses.”

That scenario played out in Norfolk, where the general manager of the transit agency resigned over operation of the rail system.

Even well-established and seemingly well-run systems like Washington D.C.’s Metro run into trouble.

Citing years of neglected repairs on the system, the Washington Post reports that Metro is experiencing more breakdowns and delays. When an aging train-location sensor failed in 2009, nine passengers were killed in a Red Line collision.

A $5 billion upgrade to the Red Line is under way, and officials say it will lead to further rider delays over the next three to four years. The $5 billion won’t touch Metro’s Yellow, Blue and Orange lines.

Layne and McAuliffe talk up The Tide extension as an economic driver in southeastern Virginia, but critics say commonwealth taxpayers should be leery of a system that depends on hefty taxpayer subsidies.

The original line cost $318.5 million to build — $106 million over budget — or $43 million per mile.

“Budget overruns are only a symptom of a problem,” O’Toole told

Lest Richmond fall in line for more “mass transit,” the Cato expert cautions:

“In order to sell it, (proponents) start by low-balling the costs. Even if the original cost projections had been accurate, it would not make sense to build light rail.”

Layne says he has no “litmus test” for green-lighting transit projects. He acknowledges the way forward is “not going to be easy.” But he added:

Passage of legislation to put new money into transportation for the first time in nearly three decades means the next transportation secretary will have more flexibility than his predecessors.

Cross-posted at

Kenric Ward

Kenric Ward

Kenric Ward is a national correspondent and writes for the Texas Bureau of Formerly a reporter and editor at two Pulitzer Prize-winning newspapers, Kenric has won dozens of state and national news awards for investigative articles. His most recent book is “Saints in Babylon: Mormons and Las Vegas.”


For your convenience, you may leave commments below using Disqus. If Disqus is not appearing for you, please disable AdBlock to leave a comment.