4 things John Kerry got wrong in a 4½-minute video

4 things John Kerry got wrong in a 4½-minute video

Secretary of State John Kerry has a new, impassioned video appeal for the U.S. Senate to consent to ratification of the U.N. Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities(CRPD). Kerry’s speechwriters should have checked their facts, though.

Among Kerry’s mistakes and mischaracterizations are the following:

  1. “[The CRPD] will help protect the rights of Americans with disabilities when they live, work, travel, or study overseas.” It will not. There is absolutely no correlation between U.S. ratification of human rights treaties and greater respect for human rights in countries that have ratified the same treaties. To say otherwise is to mislead the American community of persons with disabilities—including America’s wounded warriors—by making promises that cannot be kept.
  2. “[The CRPD] is exactly like the Americans with Disabilities Act [ADA].” If the CRPD were exactly like the ADA, it would have sailed through the Senate without objection. It’s not, which is why it was rejected on the Senate floor last December. Senator Orrin Hatch (R–UT), a strong supporter of the ADA, pointed out the differences in a July 10 floor speech (text and video available here and here) where he rightfully warned of the dangers to American sovereignty posed by ratification of the CRPD. Oddly, the CRPD even fails to define what the word disability means (which is rather important for a treaty that purports to protect persons with disabilities). The treaty instead calls disability “an evolving concept” (not very helpful).

Continue reading →


For your convenience, you may leave commments below using Disqus. If Disqus is not appearing for you, please disable AdBlock to leave a comment.